That poster is the Bow Tie model - one of the clearest ways we visualize risk in HSE.
Think of it as a bow tie lying on its side. The knot in the middle is the bad thing you don't want to happen. Left side is how you stop it from happening. Right side is how you reduce the damage if it does happen.
The shape
TOP EVENT in the center: The hazardous incident you are controlling. Example: gas release, fall from height, dropped object, loss of containment. Everything else connects to this.
Left side - THREATS & CAUSES: What could make the top event happen.
The poster lists 5 typical ones:
Equipment failure: pump fails, sling snaps
Human error: wrong valve opened, skipped step
Environmental conditions: heavy rain, high wind, poor visibility
External factors: third-party damage, power outage, sabotage
System or process weaknesses: bad design, unclear procedure
Left side barrier - Preventive Barriers: These sit between the threat and the top event. Their job is to keep the threat from becoming an incident.
On the poster:
Procedures: PTW, JSA, SOPs
Training & competence: certified operators, toolbox talks
Engineering controls: guards, interlocks, pressure relief valves
Maintenance: inspections, PM, testing
Supervision: spot checks, oversight
If those fail, the top event occurs. That's when the right side kicks in.
Right side barrier - Mitigating Barriers: These don't prevent the incident, they limit the impact after it happens.
Emergency response plan
Detection & alarms
Fire protection systems
Rescue & medical support
Business continuity: recovery, backup systems
Right side - CONSEQUENCES: What happens if all mitigation fails or is weak:
Injury or loss of life
Environmental damage
Financial loss
Equipment / asset damage
Reputation damage
Regulatory non-compliance
The yellow note says it best: Same event. Two sides. One goal - No harm. STOP THE CAUSES. BLOCK THE EVENT. REDUCE THE IMPACT.
How you build one in practice
This is the HOW IT WORKS bottom section:
List the hazards and possible causes on the left
Identify what preventive barriers you already have, and what you still need
Define the top event very clearly - not too broad, not too vague
Identify recovery / mitigating barriers on the right
List the potential consequences
Use the diagram to find gaps. Where is a barrier missing, degraded, or only on paper?
Why we love it in HSE
It shows the full picture of a risk on one page, which is perfect for risk assessments and toolbox talks
It makes barrier weaknesses visible - you can see if you have 5 preventive controls but zero mitigation
It helps you decide where to spend money and attention
It improves preparedness, because everyone understands their role on the left or right side
It directly reduces likelihood and impact
The bottom line on the poster sums up the philosophy: STRONGER BARRIERS = SAFER PEOPLE + SAFER WORKPLACES + A MORE SUSTAINABLE FUTURE
If you use it for a daily activity, try this quick check for each barrier: Is it effective? Is it actually available right now? Is someone responsible for it? If the answer is no to any, that's your gap to close. 🚧🚥🏗️🚨🗼🌡️⛑️🦺🚦⚠️

No comments:
Post a Comment